Ireland’s Gay Taoiseach– A Cause for Celebration?

After a brief leadership contest, Leo Varadkar was, on 2nd June, elected leader of Fine Gael, Ireland’s leading party. Now he has been approved by the assembly and will be sworn in as Taoiseach once his nomination is confirmed by President Higgins. This will make him Ireland’s youngest Prime Minister, the first from an ethnic minority background, and the first who is openly gay.

The son of an Indian immigrant father, and a doctor who came out in 2015, Varadkar is in many ways a welcome addition to the international political scene. Before liberals get too giddy, though, it’s worth remembering that Fine Gael are a centre-right party, and Varadkar has been described as belonging to their ‘Thatcherite’ wing. He’s neoliberal to the bone, having championed austerity and scorned the welfare state (he spearheaded a drive against benefit cheats that one social security inspector dubbed a “hate campaign”). Varadkar has also spoken of outlawing strikes in certain public services, and takes a pro-life stance towards abortion.

As with Emmanuel Macron, then, Varadkar’s ascent should be celebrated with caution. Still, this is a notable moment in a country where homosexuality was only decriminalised in 1993. In less than 25 years there’s been a remarkable acceleration in LGBTQ rights, demonstrated most notably when 63% of voters chose ‘Yes’ in a referendum on gay marriage (making Ireland the only country in the world where marriage equality was achieved by popular vote).

Varadkar becomes only the fourth openly gay head of government ever, following Iceland’s Jóhanna Sigurðardóttir, Belgium’s Elio Di Rupo and Luxembourg’s current PM Xavier Bettel (whose husband was recently included in a photo of so-called NATO ‘WAGs’). He’s also a rare example of somebody from an immigrant background leading a society, at a time when in so many other Western countries immigrants are barely even welcome.  

 His policies will prevent Varadkar from ever being the poster child of equality

Regardless of Varadkar’s political beliefs, this inevitably places Ireland at the front of the pack on visible progressiveness – another boon for a country already unusual for its lack of a far-right presence. Furthermore, having a gay Prime Minister across the border highlights just how much Northern Ireland are dragging their heels on equality, being the only part of the UK and Ireland where marriage equality is still outlawed. 

Given all this, the optics of Varadkar’s premiership are positive. Still, optics are far from everything, and it’s encouraging that within Ireland the vast majority of debate centred on his policies and character. Identity may be relevant, but it’s secondary – Varadkar’s sexuality and ethnicity haven’t stopped his supporters from supporting him, and aren't the reason his opponents oppose him. This is as it should be. It’s a prioritising of character over identity that we should remember when evaluating the likes of Theresa May and Sadiq Khan heading into the general election, and which the US might better embody the next time a Hillary or Obama jostles for their support.

His policies will prevent Varadkar from ever being the poster child of equality, but this moment is a milestone nonetheless. And in judging him on his political character, rather than largely irrelevant matters of sexuality, ethnicity, gender or faith, Ireland has set an example to the world. 

Harry Mason

More about the author

About the author

Harry Mason likes to call himself a freelance writer, even if his tax forms say he's technically a waiter. He graduated last year from the University of East Anglia, and writes predominantly about social politics and film. He looks forward to the day when he's able to grow a beard; until then, you'll just have to blame his so-called 'bleeding heart lefty views' on youthful naivety.

Follow Harry on Twitter.

Enjoyed this article?

Help us to fund independent journalism instead of buying:

Also in Disclaimer

Whatever They do to Court the Youth Vote, Hard Brexit will Taint the Tories

After years of not voting, the young have caught on and returned to the ballot box. The Conservatives are scared and are trying to come up with policies on housing and tuition fees. However, it may be that they are tainted by their nationalist approach to Brexit.

You’re Wrong, Vince. A “reverse Ukip” Could Revive the Lib Dems

Watching tumbleweed would be more interesting than 2017's Liberal Democrat Conference. Vince Cable cautiously promised to be a political adult as he opposed Brexit. However, the third party needs fire if it to avoid an ignominious death.

Forget Boris, it’s Mark Carney who hit the Brexit nail on the head

While media attention was focused on Boris Johnson's Daily Telegraph essay, Mark Carney, the Bank of England Governor laid out in cold clear detail the likely implications of Brexit. It makes for brutal but mandatory reading in these times when politicians only skim the surface.

The Universal Credit is in Crisis. Labour Should Commit to a Universal Basic Income Now

Once again, the government’s flagship welfare reform programme has been critcised for failing those it is meant to help. It is not enough for Labour to oppose the Universal Credit, they must commit to a bold reform of the Welfare State for the 21st Century.

Clinton Looks for the Truth Amid the Debris and Reclaims Her Humanity

The 2016 U.S. Presidential Election might have been reported minute-by-minute but a year later it’s still easy wonder: what on earth happened there? It’s a ripe time, then, for Hillary Clinton’s new book, What Happened, a candid examination of her devastating loss to Donald Trump.