Intelligent and Original, Lear Translates Perfectly onto Modern India

Jivan Singh returns to his childhood after a long absence, there to witness the unexpected resignation of Devraj, founding father of the Company - a vast corporation that sits at the heart of Indian life. At the same time, Devraj's daughter absconds - desperate to escape from the prospect of marriage. Her older sisters are handed control of their father's company - and there begins a vicious struggle for power, from the luxury hotels of New Delhi through to the slums of Napurthala.

India is a frequent topic for writers the world over but they rarely capture the essence of such a multi-faceted country, instead veering between semi-nostalgic tales of the British Raj, or slum set tales of poverty that blend uplifting inspiration with heavy doses of condescension. In "We That Are Young" however, author Preti Taneja takes her readers to an India that feels contemporary, modern and remarkably varied, her story offering the reader opportunities to delve deep into contrasting corners of Indian Society, but always doing so in an organic fashion - never forced but threading well into the main plot to present the reader with an intriguing and original portrait of life in modern India.

The links to King Lear are clear throughout

Now, it should be said that the plot is an adaptation of Shakespeare's King Lear, and adaptations of Shakespeare don't always read particularly well - with the myriad of Shakespeare adaptations out there, authors and directors seem desperate to stamp their mark on the work, rather than allowing the strength of Shakespeare's creations to speak for themselves. A few novels have done so admirably though, with "The Story of Edgar Sawtelle" by David Wroblewski (a retelling of Hamlet set in Wisconsin) and "A Thousand Acres" by Jane Smiley (an adaptation of King Lear set in Iowa) using new settings and time periods to help the reader discover new meanings and connections in centuries-old texts.

It is certain that "We That Are Young" will be joining those books in the ranks of original, intelligent and illuminating Shakespeare adaptations.

Taneja embeds this tale into modern-day India and makes the reader see just how good a fit it is - the wild, vital and youthful energy of India serving as a setting that, somehow, translates perfectly from Shakespeare's vision of Ancient Britain.  

The links to King Lear are clear throughout, with characters renamed to suit the Indian setting and serving the same purpose they do in Shakespeare's text, but placed into contemporary situations that, for the most part, feel hugely fitting - from Devraj's torn position as the King Lear figure through to his elderly mother's tragic background as the Fool.

 a magnificent portrait of modern-day India

The well-known plot allows author Preti Taneja to place a focus on the characters and the setting - a mix of old and new that's readable, raw and tremendously exciting. Bringing something new to a piece by Shakespeare must be a considerable challenge, but the author writes in an assured, direct and easily readable prose, and whilst this is the author’s first full-length novel, her significant experience as a journalist and academic is evident in just how smoothly readable "We That Are Young" is: the characterisations are precise and crisp, and the descriptions are perfectly placed to describe both what is a very foreign country for most, and to linger long in the mind of the reader - evocative, fragrant and sensual.

The dialogue too is something to take in, then go back a few pages and read again. It has a raw, pulsing energy to it - flowing through the book and dragging the reader along for the ride, ending on a closing speech that had me wanting to applaud. Dropping in phrases in Hindi could, in a lesser author's hands, have served to alienate the English reader, but instead feel like intimate whispers from the character to the reader - and work wonderfully in reastablishing the setting of the book.

This is a magnificent portrait of modern-day India -  a vibrant feast for the senses and full of humanity in all its horror and wonder. It’s a doorstop of a book that deserves time putting aside for - a rich treat to be devoured and digested over time. Taneja is a considerable talent - and I’m hugely excited to see what her next project is.

Luke Marlowe


Enjoyed this article?

Help us to fund independent journalism instead of buying:

Also in Disclaimer

Trump's Freak Show Might Get Top Billing in Davos But Power Lies With China

Donald Trump will become the first sitting US President to attend the World Economic Forum in Davos since Bill Clinton in 2000. While many are intrigued as to what the US president will say, it actuasloly does not matter. A year into his presidency, the world is going about its business without referenceto Washington and is, increasingly, looking east.

How Brexit puts the UK at risk of more collapses like Carillion

The construction industry has always been characterised by uncertainty. Managing large construction projects involves enormous challenges, coming from the political, economic, social and technological environments involved. Carillion’s demise shows the risks that are encountered in an industry. We should be mindful of how Brexit compounds this.

“In my Beginning is My End.” How Project Corbyn Will Fall Apart

The seeds of political downfall are sown early. Both David Cameron and Theresa May set in motion their own ends early in their leaderships. Jeremy Corbyn will be no different. The sin that will catch up with him is arrogance.

Carillion is This Week’s Watershed: But When Will Anything Change?

The collapse of Carillion is a catastrophe. 20,000 jobs are now under threat, while even more are at risk at the small firms that are owed money. But this is not the only disaster of recent times. The common theme from Grenfell Tower to GS4 at the 2012 Olympics is private sector outsourcing.

After a Lost Decade, Time for our Leaders to “Raise Their Game”

Nick Boles was right to warn that Theresa May needs to raise her game. She is offering second-rate leadership and has no domestic agenda. Even worse, her opponent Jeremy Corbyn is not offering an thought-through alternative. Britain is still ducking the challenges a decade after the banking crisis.